Another view on representations and warranties
This article will address issues relating to representations and warranties as they arise in the common law, not in the context of the Uniform Commercial Code.
We will begin with representations. They are statements of present or past fact. Future "facts" cannot generally form the basis of representations because no one can know the future.
If a representation is intentionally false, a plaintiff can make a common law claim of deceit (a tort) and allege fraudulent misrepresentation.
Generally, a plaintiff injured by a fraudulent misrepresentation has a choice of remedies. She may rescind the contract and obtain restitutionary recovery, or she may affirm the contract and sue for damages. The ability to rescind - to unwind a closed transaction - is a remedy not available to a plaintiff suing for a breach of warranty, and therefore is a benefit of including representations in a contract. A second benefit is that the plaintiff may be able to obtain punitive damages under special circumstances.
Now, let's turn to warranties. A common law warranty isa promise that a fact is true. According to the New York court, a warranty is a promise of indemnity if a statement of fact is false. A promisee does not have to believe that the statement is true. Indeed, the warranty's purpose is to relieve a promisee from the
Consider the statements below:
- I. Representations and warranties are not inextricably linked. Some parties, as a matter of principle, refuse to take fraud risk (read punitive damages), and will not make representations, only warranties.
- II. Representations, if shown to be false, and if the injured party knew them to be false, can give cause for the rescission of the agreement and the party making the representation can be sued for fraud.
- III. A plaintiff may be able to win a breach of warranty claim when it would have lost a claim for fraudulent misrepresentation because it could not prove that the defendant knew the representation to be false.
According to the text